The case for banning the burqa
Mike Mercury
Feminist exception
Western feminism spent decades insisting that personal preference does not close the conversation when that preference is shaped by systems that constrain what preference can look like. That reasoning dismantled arguments about beauty standards and industries far less coercive than religious orthodoxy.
Applied here — to a garment entire governments have made compulsory — the same movement suddenly finds the question too delicate to pursue.
None of this requires hostility to Islam, to faith, or to religious expression broadly understood.
The headscarf is not the burqa. Private devotion is not public concealment.
People are entitled to their beliefs, entitled to wear almost anything behind their own doors, entitled to worship as conscience directs.
But public space is shared space, and shared space carries shared obligations.
Turning your face away from those obligations — permanently, behind fabric, as a matter of principle — is less religious liberty than a form of civic withdrawal.
There is a meaningful distance between religious expression and civic withdrawal. The burqa travels the full length of it.
Open society? Closed case
British polling puts support for a ban at 56%. For once, democratic instinct and reasoned argument are pulling in the same direction — not always a luxury policymakers enjoy.
In America, a federal ban would face genuine First Amendment scrutiny. The constitutional architecture differs, the judicial culture differs, the politics differ enormously.
But “legally complicated” and “morally unclear” are not synonyms.
Many Americans who correctly distrust government overreach have no difficulty concluding that facial concealment in courtrooms, classrooms, and government offices warrants regulation.
The legal pathway varies by country. The underlying social logic does not.
The burqa is not compatible with open societies. The only remaining question is how long open societies intend to pretend otherwise.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.