When did MAGA become Make Argentina Great Again?
On May 19, President Donald Trump’s Department of Agriculture unveiled its so-called “Farmers First” policy initiative with an aggressive marketing campaign. There was a press conference with Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins, a social media campaign promoting the initiative and a glossy pamphlet trumpeting the hard work and dignity of America’s family farmers.
Five months later, America’s farmers are collateral damage in the administration’s worldwide trade war.
The economic situation in farm country is increasingly dire. In my home state of Minnesota, soybean farmers are buckling under the weight of the president’s tariffs, which have decimated their most important export markets. I sat down with many of them last month in Lakeville, Minnesota, to talk about how tariffs are driving up input costs and putting the squeeze on their operations.
Nationally, farm bankruptcies are up 57% in 2025 compared to 2024. And with 27% of our nation’s farmers and ranchers relying on the Affordable Care Act for health coverage, too many rural Americans will face skyrocketing healthcare costs when Republicans let the ACA tax credits expire at the end of the year.
TRUMP SCORES FOUR BIG WINS WITH XI, BUT HAS ONE BIG MISS
While farmers wind down the harvest season without their previously reliable customers, like China, lined up to buy their product, you’d think the administration might reignite its “Farmers First” agenda. Instead, President Trump is using his power to boost one of our top agricultural competitors and kick American farmers while they’re down. Enter: his $40 billion taxpayer-funded bailout to Argentina.
Argentina is the third-largest soybean producer in the world after Brazil and the United States. And since President Trump alienated China – the world’s largest buyer of soybeans – with tariffs, Argentine soybean farmers have effectively replaced American farmers.
In October, Argentine farmers sold 2.5 million metric tons of soybeans to China – while American soybean farmers sold basically zero. In a typical year, China buys over 50% of U.S.-grown soybeans, generating around $13 billion for U.S. farmers each crop year. That’s $13 billion worth of soybean exports down the drain.
President Trump is claiming his recent meeting with his “very, very good friend,” President Xi Jinping of China, who pledged to resume purchases of U.S.-grown soybeans at levels last seen under the Biden administration, is the bright light at the end of a very painful tunnel.
After nearly a year of manufactured crisis in farm country, the dealmaker-in-chief has secured a vague promise from China to return to the status quo. And that is if the deal manages to migrate from fantasy to reality. China bought none of the $200 billion in extra U.S. exports that it promised after striking a “deal” with Trump following his trade war with China during his first administration.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE FOX NEWS OPINION
America’s farmers are hurting, and tariffs are hiking the cost of living beyond farm country, too. Year to year, food is up 3%, beef prices are at record highs, and coffee, with an increase of over 19%, is no longer a cheap caffeine fix.
Despite Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent declaring the bailout “mission critical,” the president has openly admitted that the American people will not benefit from his $40 billion giveaway to Argentina. And we know American farmers certainly won’t. Maybe that’s why a majority of voters disapprove of the administration’s Argentina bailout.
In fact, the only people who will benefit from this bailout are President Trump and his ally, Argentine President Javier Milei, whose corrupt politics have driven Argentina into an economic crisis. Well, and the Wall Street financiers who placed bad bets on his unstable economy.
And the president isn’t just bailing out Argentina’s bankers – he’s bailing out their farm sector, too. Recently, the president outraged American ranchers by announcing a plan to quadruple Argentine beef imports – throwing cattle markets into turmoil and hitting U.S. cattlemen squarely in the pocketbook after years of drought and down markets pushed them to the brink.
If there is any semblance of truth to “Farmers First” – or “America First,” for that matter – President Trump should end his affair with Argentina and focus on the Americans struggling here at home.
CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM REP. ANGIE CRAIG
You may also like
By mfnnews
Archives
Categories
- 039217
- 0538
- 11-year-old girl suspect
- 2016 Election
- 2020 Election
- 2020 riots
- 2024
- 2024 democratic primary
- 2024 election
- 2024 presidential election
- 2025 elections
- 2025 mayoral race
- 2025 New York City mayoral race
- 2026 elections
- 2026 midterms
- 2028 democratic presidential primary
- 2028 election
- 2028 presidential election
- 2nd Amendment
- 5g
- 60 Minutes
- 9/11
- A Further Perspective
- Abide
- Abigail spanberger
- Abortion
- ACA subsidies
- Academia
- Academics
- ACLU
- Activist courts
- Activist judge
- Activist judges
- Adam schiff
- Administration
- Adolf hitler
- Affirmative action
- Affordability
- Africa
- Ag
- Ai
- Ai companion
- Ai friendship
- Aipac
- airbnb
- Airport
- Al robertson
- Al sharpton
- Alabama
- Alex Marlow
- Alexandria
- Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
- Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC)
- Aliens
- Align
- Align cars
- All saints day
- Allie beth stuckey
- America
- America Ripe for Reform
- American history
- American trucking
- American trucking associations
- American trucking industry
- Americana
- Americans for public trust
- Analysis
- Andrew Cuomo
- Andrew McCabe
- Andy Beshear
- Andy Biggs
- Anglican
- Animals
- Anita dunn
- Another Perspective
- Anthony bernal
- Anthony fauci
- anti-Christian attacks
- Anti-ice attack
- anti-Israel
- Anti-Semitism
- Antifa
- antisemitism
- António guterres
- Antony Fauci
- Ap-norc poll
- Apportionment
- Arabcon
- Archbishop of canterbury
- Arctic
- Arctic frost
- Arctic frost investigation
- Argentina
- Argentine
- Arizona
- Arizona agribusiness and equine center public charter school
- Army
- Arnold schwarzenegger
- arrest
- arrested
- Arson
- Artificial intelligence
- Asia
- Assassination
- Assassination of charlie kirk
- Assassination prep
- Assassination prep campaign
- Associated Press
- Atmospheric Rivers
- Attack on ice officers
- Attorney general
- Attorney general matthew platkin
- Auron macintyre
- Auto industry
- Automobiles
- Autopen
- Avril Lavigne
- Ayanna Pressley
- Baby
- Bad teacher
- Ballots
- Barack Obama
- Bari weiss
- Bari weiss takes over cbs
- Barry goldwater
- Baseball
- Basketball
- Bbc
- beach
- Becca rothfeld
- Ben Stein's Diary
- Benjamin Netanyahu
- Beto o'rourke
- Bible
- Biblical truth
- Biden
- Biden administration
- Biden lawfare
- Biden presidency
- Big Government
- Big Media
- Big Pharma
- Big tech
- Bill essayli
- Bill gates
- Biographies
- Birds
- Birth rate
- Black lives matter
- Black lives matter global network foundation
- Blanche v. perlmutter
- Blaze Media
- Blaze tv
- Blazetv
- BLM
- Blm fraud
- Blog
- Blue States
- Boasberg
- Boko Haram
- Bomb threats
- Book reviews
- Books
- Border patrol
- Boris johnson
- Boston
- Boston College
- bounty
- Boy stuffed into freezer
- Brain rot
- Brandon Johnson
- BRazil
- Breaking Security
- Breitbart
- Breitbart Business Digest
- Breitbart News Saturday
- Brendan carr
- Brian harrison
- Brian Kelly
- Brian stack
- Brit Hume
- Britain
- Bronx
- Bronx anti-war coalition
- Brutal beating
- Budget Deficit
- Bulgaria
- Bureaucracy
- Bureaucrats
- Burma
- Business
- Business & Economy
- Butterfly named after zarutska
- Buy the Book
- C.P. Cavafy
- CAIR
- California
- California election
- California failure
- California murder
- California vs texas
- California Watch
- Cambodia
- Camera phone
- Campaign
- Campaign bus fire
- Campaign Crawlers
- Campus
- Campus Protests
- Canada
- Candidate
- Capitol police
- Caregiver
- Caregiving
- Caretaker
- Caribbean
- Carrie
- Carrier
- cartel
- Cartel Crackdown
- Catherine Cortez Masto
- Catholicism
- Caught on video
- Cbs
- Cbs news
- CCP
- Ceasefire
- Cenk uygur
- Censorship
- Centers for medicare and medicaid services
- Central Intelligence Agency
- Characterai
- Charge
- charges
- Charles k. voorhees
- Charlie Kirk
- Charlie Kirk Assassination
- Charlotte
- Chatbot
- Chatgpt
- Cheap labors
- Chemistry
- Cheney
- Chicago
- Chicago police
- Chick-fil-a lethal attack
- Child sex abuse material
- Child sex conviction
- Children
- China
- Chinese Communist Party
- Cholera
- Chris coons
- Chris jansing
- Chris wray
- Chris Wright
- Christian
- Christian parenting
- Christian Persecution
- Christianity
- Christians
- Christopher hohn
- Christopher wray
- Chuck grassley
- Chuck schumer
- Church of england
- Churchill
- CIA
- Citizenship
- Civic education
- Civics
- Civil war
- Civility
- Climate alarmism
- Climate change
- Climate hysteria
- Clips
- Clot shot
- Cms
- CNN
- Cnn creators
- Coal
- Cocaine
- Cognitive decline
- Cold War
- College
- College football
- College Republicans
- Colonel Tom Parker
- Colorado
- Columbia University
- Columns
- Comedy
- Comer
- Comet
- Comey
- Comirnaty
- Communism
- Commutations
- Congress
- Congress Blog
- Connie linen death
- Conservative
- Conservative history
- Conservative Review
- Conservatives
- Conspiracy theories
- Constitution
- Construction
- Continuing Resolution (CR)
- contract
- Cops
- Corporal punishment
- Corporate media
- Corruption
- Corruption Chronicles
- Cory kapahulehua
- Court Battles
- COVID-19
- Crime
- Crime thwarted
- Crime Time
- Critical race theory
- crocodile
- Cultural Decline
- Cultural Depravity
- Culture
- Culture war
- Cuomo vs mamdani
- Curtis Sliwa
- Cybernetics
- D.c.
- Daily Caller
- Daily Caller News Foundation
- Dan Osborn
- Daniel Richman
- Dark money
- Darryl lee jr of kankakee
- David french
- David remnick
- Davis ingle
- DC Exclusives – Blog
- DC Exclusives – Blurb
- DC Exclusives – Freelance
- DC Exclusives – Opinion
- DC Exclusives – Original Reporting
- Dead
- Dearborn islamic attack
- Deb Fischer
- Debora patta
- Decarlos brown
- Declaration of Independence
- Defense
- Defense & National Security
- Defund the police
- DEI
- Dei lawsuit
- Dei woke lawsuit
- Delta Air Lines
- Dementia
- Democracy
- Democrat
- Democrat deathwish scandal
- Democrat extortion
- Democrat indicted
- Democrat party
- Democrat shutdown
- Democratic Party
- Democratic Socialism
- Democratic Socialists of America
- democrats
- Dennis Prager
- Deparment of Homeland Security
- Department of education
- Department of Energy
- Department of homeland security
- Department of Homeland Security (DHS)
- Department of Justice
- Department of transportation
- department of war
- Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche
- Devil
- DHS
- Dhs shots fired
- Dick cheney
- Diplomacy
- Disaster aid
- disinformation
- District court
- District of columbia
- Dmv
- Doge
- Doha
- DOJ
- Doj vs blm
- Don lemon
- Donald Trump
- Doomsday
- Dreamworks
- Drug trafficking gangs
- Drugs
- DSA
- early voting
- East Wing
- East Wing demolition
- EBT
- Economic Growth
- Economy
- Ed martin
- Education
- Education Gone Wild
- Education reform
- Ehud barak
- Election
- Election day
- Election fraud
- election integrity
- Election reform
- election results
- Elections
- Elections 2028
- Electoral college
- Electric vehicles
- elementary school
- Eligibility
- Elivs Presley
- Elon musk
- Email hacked
- Emergency docket
- Emilia Sykes
- Energy
- Energy & Environment
- energy bills
- England
- Entertainment
- Eretz Yisrael
- Eric Swalwell
- Erika Kirk
- Espionage
- Estrangement
- Euro Watch
- Europe
- European union
- exclusive
- executions
- Executive power
- Exxon
- Faith
- Family
- Family terrorized
- Fani willis
- Fannie Mae
- Far-left
- Farming
- Farmland
- Fatal shooting
- Fatal shootings
- Fauci
- Fbi
- FBI Director James Comey
- Fbi investigation
- Fbi thwarts attack
- Fdr
- Fearless
- Fearless with jason whitlock
- Federal Aviation Administration
- Federal bureau of invesitgation
- Federal bureau of investigation
- federal employees
- Federal reserve
- FEMA
- Feminism
- Fentanyl
- Ferndale attack
- Fight
- Fight video
- fighter jet
- Fights
- Filibuster
- Finance
- Finland
- First Trump administration
- First-person
- flooding
- Florida
- Florida woman
- Flynn Files
- Foia
- Food
- Food aid benefits
- Food insecurity
- Food lion
- Food stamps
- Foreign Affairs
- Foreign Policy
- Fox News
- France
- Franklin D. Roosevelt
- Fraud
- Freddie Mac
- Free
- Free Market
- Free speech
- Free the Market
- Freedom
- Freedom of information act request
- Gambling
- Gary player
- Gates
- Gavin newsom
- Gayle King
- Gaza
- Gaza humanitarian foundation
- Gaza strip
- Gaza War
- Gen Z
- Gender Identity
- gender ideology
- Genocide
- George clooney
- George Floyd
- George Soros
- George W. Bush
- Georgetown University
- Gerrymander
- Gerrymandering
- Gerrymandering battle
- Ghazala hashmi
- Ghosts
- Giovanni spirea
- Girl
- Girls Sports
- Glassboro
- Glenn beck
- Global Disinformation Index
- Global Engagement Center
- Global warming
- GMA News
- Gnag
- God
- Golf
- Gospel
- Government
- Government overreach
- Government Shutdown
- Governor
- Governors
- GPA
- Gps
- Grade Inflation
- Graham platner
- Grandson kills grandmother
- Grassley
- Great Depression
- Greece
- Green energy
- Grocery Prices
- Grocery store riots
- Grooming
- Gubernatorial race
- H-1b visas
- Hakeem Jeffries
- Halloween
- Halloween 2025
- Halloween attack plot
- Halloween terror plot
- Hamas
- Hamas israel
- Harvard
- Harvard law school
- Harvard medical school
- Harvard University
- Haunting
- Health
- Health Care
- Health insurance
- Heist
- helicopter crash
- Hell
- Helmet
- Heritage Foundation
- high school football
- Higher Education
- History
- Hoke county sheriff's office
- Hollywood
- Home depot
- Homelessness
- Homeschool
- Homeschooling
- hospital
- Hospitals
- House
- House of representatives
- House republicans
- Housing
- Howard university
- Hugh Hewitt
- Hungary
- Hurricane
- Hurricane Melissa
- ICE
- Ilhan Omar
- illegal aliens
- Illegal gambling
- Illegal immigrants
- Illegal immigration
- Illegal immigration crisis
- illinois
- Immigration
- Immigration and customs enforcement
- Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)
- Immigration crisis
- Impeachment
- In Memoriam
- In Print Fall 2025
- In The Know
- In The News
- Independence Day
- Independent agencies
- India
- Indiana
- Industrialization
- Inflation
- International
- Intruder
- Iran
- Iraq
- Ireland
- Iryna zarutska
- Iryna's azure butterfly
- Islam
- Isolation
- Israel
- Israel / Middle East
- Ivy league
- J. michael seabright
- J6
- Jack brewer
- Jack Ciattarelli
- Jack smith
- Jacky Rosen
- Jamaica
- James boasberg
- James comer
- James Comey
- Jan. 6 Capitol riot
- Janelle bynum
- Janet mills
- January 6
- January 6 footage
- Japan
- Jared isaacman
- Jase robertson
- Jasmine crockett
- Jason miyares
- Jason whitlock
- Javier milei
- Jay Jones
- Jay jones text scandal
- Jay jones texts
- JB Pritzker
- Jd vance
- Jean-pierre
- Jennifer Lawrence
- Jesse Watters
- jewish community
- Jihadi terror attack
- Jihadists
- Jk rowling
- Joe Biden
- Joe rogan
- John F. Kennedy International Airport
- John fetterman
- John leguizamo
- John Lennon
- John Nolte
- John reid
- John thune
- Jon stewart
- Joy behar
- Jr tolkien
- judge
- Judicial nominees
- Judicial Watch
- Julia roberts
- Just The News
- Justin bieber
- Kamala harris
- Karine
- Karine Jean-Pierre
- Kat Abughazaleh
- Kathy Hochul
- Katie Hobbs
- Kcoree warren death
- Kenvue
- Kesley grammer
- Kevin Roberts
- Kimberly-clark
- Kjp
- Knife and hammer murder
- Kristen Welker
- Kristi noem
- Labor Unions
- Latest News
- Latin America
- Laughing Matters
- Law
- Law & Order
- Law and Order
- Lawfare
- Leftist
- Legal opinion
- Letitia James
- Levin
- Levintv
- LGBTQ
- Liberal media
- Liberals mock transgenders
- Libs embarrassed online
- Libs melt down on social media
- Lifestyle
- Lincoln university
- Lindsey byman
- Loneliness
- Lord of the rings
- Los Angeles
- Los Angeles Wildfires
- Loudoun County
- Louvre
- LSU Tigers
- Lucas county sheriff's office
- Lynwood murder
- MAGA
- Maga christianity
- Maggie aragon
- Maine
- Maine Senate
- Mainstream Media
- Major League Baseball
- Mamdani
- Mar-a-Lago
- Margaret brennan
- Margaret Thatcher
- Maricopa county sheriff's office
- Marijuana
- Marina samuel
- Marine Corps
- Mark levin
- Marriage
- Mars
- Mary maccudden
- Masculinity
- Mass shootings
- Massachusetts
- Matt Towery
- Mayor
- Mayoral election
- Media
- Media city
- Medicaid
- Medicare
- Medicare advantage
- Meet the Press
- Megyn kelly
- Men
- Mexico
- Michael david booth
- Michael jordan
- Michael rapaport
- Michigan terror scheme
- Microsoft
- Middle east
- Midterm Election
- Migrants
- Mike braun
- Mike howell
- Mike Lawler
- Mikie Sherrill
- Military
- Milley
- Minimum Wage
- minor
- Mississippi
- Mississippi delta
- Missouri murders
- Momence
- Money
- Mother
- Movies
- Mr crafty pants
- Mre
- Murder
- Murder for hire plot
- Music
- Muslim
- Muslism
- NAACP
- Nancy Mace
- Narco-Terror
- nashville
- National Football League
- National Guard
- National Review
- National Security
- Navy
- Ndaa
- Nebraska
- New Culture Vultures
- New era democrats
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New jersey governor race
- New jersey polling locations
- New york
- New York City
- new york city general election
- New York City Mayor's Race
- New York City Mayoral Race
- New York Jets
- New York Post
- New York Special
- New york times
- News
- Newsletter: China Watch
- Newsletter: Defense Report
- Newsletter: NONE
- Newsletter: Politics and Elections
- Newsletter: the border report
- Newsletter: The Lineup
- Newsletters
- Newsom 2028
- Newsom vs rogan
- Nexstar Media Wire News
- Nick Fuentes
- Nicolas Maduro
- Nigeria
- Nigerian
- North carolina
- North carolina crime
- Nrcc
- Nuclear weapons
- Nyc
- Nyc mayoral campaign
- Nyc mayoral race
- Nyc polling locations
- Nypd
- Oct. 7
- October 7
- Ohio
- Old glory
- On The Hill
- Ontario police
- Opinion
- Opinion & analysis
- Oregon
- Oversight committee
- Oversight project
- Pacific Northwest
- Palestine
- Palestinian islamic jihad
- Pam bondi
- Pardon
- Pardons
- parents
- Parents kill child
- password
- Past Is Prologue
- Patriot Awards
- Peek Op-Ed
- Perp walk
- Persecution
- Pete Hegseth
- Pete Ricketts
- Peter Strzok
- Pfizer
- Physical attack
- Platner
- Plays
- Podcast
- Police
- Police arrested
- Policy
- Political Hay
- Political sextortion
- Politics
- Polk county sheriff's office
- Polls
- Polyamory
- Population
- Population Crisis
- Population Decline
- Portland
- prank
- Pre-Viral
- President Trump
- Press Releases
- Prices
- prison
- Project 2025
- pronouns
- Proposition 50 gerrymandering
- Prosecutor
- puberty blockers
- Public Depravity
- public school
- Purity
- Queens
- Quincy spears
- Radical Muslim Group
- Radio
- Rand paul
- Rebecca kadaga
- Red and blue
- Red planet
- Redistricting
- Redistricting proposition
- Relatable
- Relatable with allie beth stuckey
- Relationship
- Religion
- Renovations
- Representation
- Republicans
- Restaurant workers attacked
- Results of 2020 election
- Retirement
- Return
- Revival
- Richard Ebright
- Riley Gaines
- Riot
- Riots
- Rob bonta
- Rob Manfred
- Robbery
- Robert De Niro
- Robertson family
- Rock
- Ron desantis
- Russia
- Russiagate
- Samhain
- Sanctuary policies
- Sara gonzales
- Sara gonzales unfiltered
- Sarah mullally
- Satan
- Satellite
- Satire
- Scarlett johnson
- School
- School Shooting
- Schroeder’s Corner
- Schumer Shutdown
- Scott Jennings
- Scotus
- Sean Hannity
- Sen dalya attar
- Sen. josh hawley
- Senate
- Senate Democrats
- Senate republicans
- Sentinel island
- sex
- Sharing
- Shark
- Sheldon whitehouse
- Sheriff grady judd
- Sheriffs arrested
- Shira Perlmutter
- Shootings
- Showbiz
- Shut down
- Shutdown
- Silicon Valley
- Snap
- Snap benefits
- Snap benefits to end
- Snap program
- socialism
- South africa
- South america
- South Carolina
- Space
- Space race
- Spanberger vs earle-sears
- Spanking
- Special Event
- Special session
- Sports
- Sports Arena
- Stabbing
- Stalin
- State Watch
- Statutory rape
- Stephen king
- Stephen Miller
- Steve bannon
- Steve scalise
- Students for Justice in Palestine
- Suffolk polling
- Superintelligence
- Supernatural
- Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program
- Supreme Court
- Surveillance
- Susan collins
- Suspects throw chair at police officer
- Tara Palmeri
- Tariffs
- Tarriffs
- Taxes
- Teacher arrested
- Teacher sex scandal
- Teacher student sex scandal
- Tech
- Technology
- TED Talk
- Telegraph
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Texas dmv
- The Alex Marlow Show
- The American Spectator
- The Arena
- The auron macintyre show
- The Big Short
- The charlie effect
- The Covenant School
- The Cultural Dispatch
- The Current Crisis
- The Daily Wire
- The glenn beck program
- The Hill
- The Ingraham Angle
- The Late Show with Stephen Colbert
- The mist
- The New York Times
- The stand
- The view
- The Washington Free Beacon
- Thomas massie
- Threats against republicans
- Threats online
- Thwarted terror plot
- Tiktok
- Toledo
- Tolkien
- Tom colicchio
- Tom Fitton's Judicial Watch Weekly Update
- Tom Homan
- Tommy robinson
- Tpusa
- Trade
- trade deficit
- Transcripts
- Transgender
- Transgender agenda
- Transgender as an insult
- Transportation
- Tricia mclaughlin
- Trucking industry
- True crime
- True crime news
- Trump
- Trump admin
- Trump administration
- Trump Derangement Syndrome
- Trump endorses cuomo
- Trump vs mamdani
- Trump vs the courts
- Trump white house renovation
- TRUTH Social
- Tucker Carlson
- Turning Point USA
- Tylenol
- Tyler maxon avalos
- Tyler robinson
- Uganda
- Uk
- Uk glamour mag
- Unashamed
- Uncategorized
- United kingdom
- Universities
- University
- University of mississippi
- University of pennsylvania
- Upload
- Us military strike
- Usaa
- Usda
- Vaccination
- Vaccine
- Valentine's Day
- Vance
- Vance presidential ticket
- Vance vs rubio
- Vance-rubio 2028
- Venezuala
- Video
- Video phone
- Viral video
- Virginia
- Virginia attorney general election
- Virginia elections
- Virginia gubernatorial race
- Visas
- Voter fraud
- voter identification
- voting
- Vulgar email sent
- Vulnerable
- War fighting
- Watergate
- Watseka
- Weaponization
- Weather
- White House
- White house ballroom
- Who will win nyc mayor
- Wic
- William holmes
- Winsome earle-sears
- Woke universities
- Women of the year
- WWII
- Youtube influencer arrest
- Zach dasher
- Zohran
- Zohran Mamdani

Leave a Reply